A Life Shaped by Shadows
Born on June 30, 1901, in the gritty Irishtown neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York, William Francis Sutton Jr. grew up in a world where poverty was a constant companion. His father, a blacksmith, toiled long hours, while his mother battled depression after losing a daughter. By age nine, Willie was already dipping his toes into crime, burglarizing local stores. His early brushes with theft set the stage for a career that would see him steal an estimated $2 million from over 100 banks. Known as “Willie the Actor” and “Slick Willie” for his clever disguises, Sutton’s life was a blend of audacity and charm. He never carried a loaded gun, claiming he feared hurting anyone, and his polite demeanor during heists earned him a reputation as a gentleman thief. One witness likened his robberies to a cinematic experience, “except the usher had a gun” (FBI Historical Records).
Sutton’s first major score came at 17, lifting $16,000 from a shipyard office, but it was his 1930 robbery of a Broadway jeweler for $100,000 that thrust him into the spotlight. His knack for slipping into roles—policeman, mailman, or diplomat—made him a master of deception. Yet, his charm didn’t keep him out of trouble. Arrested multiple times, he spent over half his adult life behind bars, only to escape three maximum-security prisons with a flair that rivaled his heists. His story, detailed in his memoirs I, Willie Sutton (1953) and Where the Money Was (1976), paints a vivid picture of a man who saw bank robbery as an art form, driven not just by money but by the thrill of the chase.
Escapes That Defied Belief
Sutton’s prison breaks were as legendary as his robberies. In 1932, while serving a 30-year sentence at Sing Sing, he used a smuggled gun to hold a guard hostage and scaled a 30-foot wall with a 45-foot ladder. His most daring escape came on February 10, 1947, from Holmesburg Prison in Philadelphia. Disguised as a guard, Sutton and four others lashed together ladders made from mop strands and crossed the yard in a snowstorm. When a searchlight caught them, Sutton shouted, “It’s okay!” convincing the guards to stand down. They commandeered a milk truck, toasted their freedom with stolen milk, and fled (FBI Historical Records). This escape, one of three successful breaks, cemented his reputation as a Houdini-like figure. The FBI, frustrated by his elusiveness, added him to their Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list on March 20, 1950, just a week after its creation.
His final capture in 1952 was a twist of fate. A 24-year-old tailor’s son, Arnold Schuster, recognized Sutton on a Brooklyn subway and tipped off the police. Sutton, living quietly under the alias Charles Gordon, was arrested with $7,723 in cash and a .38-caliber pistol. Tragically, Schuster’s act of civic duty cost him his life when Mafia boss Albert Anastasia, angered by the “squealer,” ordered his murder. Sutton, however, denied any involvement in the 1950 Manufacturers Trust Company robbery in Queens, for which he was convicted and sentenced to 30 years to life. His trial, presided over by Judge Peter T. Farrell, highlighted his complex persona: a criminal genius who never admitted to the crimes pinned on him but whose fingerprints told a different story.
The Myth of “That’s Where the Money Is”
Sutton is forever linked to the phrase, “I rob banks because that’s where the money is,” a quip that inspired “Sutton’s Law” in fields like medicine and accounting, urging focus on the most obvious solutions. Yet, in his 1976 memoir Where the Money Was, Sutton denied ever saying it, attributing the line to a journalist’s embellishment. The earliest known use of the phrase appeared in a 1923 Detroit Free Press article about another robber, Paul Perritt, suggesting it was a trope that stuck to Sutton’s legend. He admitted he might have said it if asked, as it was “obvious,” but insisted his true motive was the adrenaline rush: “I was more alive when I was inside a bank, robbing it, than at any other time in my life” (Quote Investigator).
After his release from Attica State Prison on Christmas Eve 1969, commuted due to poor health, Sutton lived quietly in Spring Hill, Florida, until his death on November 2, 1980, at age 79. His later years saw him consult on bank security and even star in a 1970 commercial for a Connecticut bank’s photo credit card program—an ironic twist for a man who once targeted their vaults. His legacy endures through his books and the 2011 documentary In the Footsteps of Willie Sutton, which traces his life from Brooklyn’s streets to the FBI’s most-wanted list. For those intrigued by his story, visiting Brooklyn’s Vinegar Hill or the FBI’s historical archives offers a glimpse into the world of this enigmatic folk hero.
Comments
Comments section coming soon!